REVIEW: Conan #4 Highlights Old, New Fan Dissonance

By BOB FREEMAN – Paint Monk’s Library Writer

There seems to be a real disconnect between the old guard Conan fans, particularly those of us who are Howard obsessive, and the younger creators and collectors. We Howard purists have always had issues whenever the Cimmerian has been depicted out of character or when things fail to line up properly with the Hyborian Age as writ by Cross Plains
favorite son.

Robert E. Howard created a world that was visceral, that felt real at its core, and that attention to detail made Conan and those who inhabited the Hyborian Kingdoms seem like authentic, historical figures.

For these younger fans, who have entered into a fandom already diluted by unfaithful movies, cartoons, tv series, comics, and pastiches, see Conan as just another intellectual property where anything goes.

For those of us who were there before any of that, when the most we had to concern ourselves with was L. Sprague DeCamp’s meddling and the odd misfire by Roy Thomas, well, these modern takes on the Cimmerian are a hard pill to swallow.

A hard pill to swallow indeed.

Synopsis: Conan the Barbarian #4 (2019)

The cover for Conan the Barbarian #4 (2019).

King Conan of Aquilonia reflects on his climb to power and of the mind-numbing banality of holding court. He becomes ill, but shuns his healers, praying for an invading army to lift his spirits. Seeking a more primal cure for his ills, he engages a caged lion, challenging it to a fight.

The lion, however, sensing his own kind in the Cimmerian, befriends the king instead. They become inseperable. The King then decides on a plan to scratch his adventuring itch: donning a skull mask, Conan and his lion prowl the streets of Aquilonia, killing criminals and cutthroats like a Hyborian age Batman and Robin until eventually the king returns the lion to the jungles of Koth.

It’s a bird…it’s a plane…it’s Bat-Barbarian?

CAPSULE REVIEW: First things first, right out of the gate. It’s King Numedides, not Namedides. Where are the editors on this book?

I’m just going to say it: I hated this book with a passion. The lone saving grace was Gerardo Zaffino’s artwork, which was more inline with what we’re seeing over on Savage Sword. It’s got energy, and while it’s not what I would consider my preferred style of draughtsmanship, it captures the spirit this comic needs.

Unfortunately, Jason Aaron’s tale is proposterous. Conan as a masked crime fighter? King by day, Batman by night? It is an unfortunate premise and does not bode well for the series as a whole.

On a scale of 1-10 skulls of my enemies, I would rate this issue worthy of a 5, solely for the artwork.

Alba Gu Brath – Bob Freeman (aka The Occult Detective)

Both comments and pings are currently closed.
0 0 vote
Article Rating
6 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Terry Allen

Don't forget they've got to get him into super-hero mode for his team-ups with the Avengers , Wolverine etc. *sigh*! I agree not keen how this looks like it might be going with Conan.

Bob Freeman

I'm with you, Terry. This bodes ill for Marvel's caretaking of the character.

John Jack

Fully agree that it was very out of character for Conan to become a masked vigilante,that said I had a good time and your introduction comes off a bit elitist.

Michael Syrigos

Why bother with the complexities of a harsh, politically incorrect world and try to make your character live through it's complexities when it's easier to the monthly format to make the barbarian character a typical super hero with all te tropes this includes?

Jerry Kimbro

Wow. Is it true? Is Marvel really gone so far down the tubes that they can't even write a half decent Conan story? Did they wait too late to bring Conan back? That is rapidly becoming the real issue with CTB. I was enthused and thrilled to wait for each issue. No, they bring me chagrin and anxiety. This not what Howard would have wanted to see.
The Death of Conan indeed.

Conn

Noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!